Reel in the Adventure: Top 15 Best Fly Fishing Trips in Pennsylvania

Best Fly Fishing Trips in Pennsylvania

Pennsylvania, the Keystone State, is a hidden gem for fly fishing enthusiasts. With its diverse landscapes, pristine waters, and abundant trout, it offers some of the finest fly fishing experiences in the eastern United States. Whether you’re a seasoned angler or a novice looking to cast your first line, Pennsylvania has it all.

So, grab your rod, tie your flies, and get ready for an angler’s adventure through the Top 15 best fly fishing trips in Pennsylvania. Pennsylvania’s waterways are a haven for those seeking the tranquility and excitement of fly fishing.

1. Penns Creek

Penns Creek
Image by Steve on Flickr

Penns Creek in the picturesque valleys of Pennsylvania, is a fly-fishing paradise that beckons anglers from far and wide. Known for its pristine waters and thriving trout population, this iconic stream offers an exhilarating fly-fishing experience.

Penns Creek is a year-round haven for fly anglers, offering diverse opportunities for both beginners and seasoned experts. Its cold, clear waters are home to wild brown, rainbow, and brook trout, providing a challenging and rewarding fishing adventure. The creek meanders through lush forests, creating a serene and idyllic backdrop for your angling pursuits.

What sets Penns Creek apart is its famous Green Drake hatch, a natural spectacle that draws anglers and entices trout alike. Witnessing this hatch is a remarkable experience, as the air fills with the gentle flutter of these large mayflies, and the water comes alive with hungry fish. Timing your visit to coincide with this event is a must for any fly-fishing enthusiast.

Whether you’re casting dry flies during a hatch or nymphing in the quieter stretches, Penns Creek promises unforgettable moments for all who venture here as one of the best fly fishing trips in Pennsylvania. With its pristine beauty and challenging waters, it’s no wonder that it remains a cherished destination for fly fishermen seeking the thrill of the catch amidst nature’s splendor.

2. Lake Erie

Lake Erir
Image via Coe Vanna Charters

Fly fishing in Lake Erie may not be on the radar of traditionalists who stick to trout in rivers and streams, but it’s a hidden gem waiting to be explored. This expansive lake, shared by several states including Pennsylvania, offers a diverse and exhilarating fishing experience that defies conventions.

Lake Erie boasts a thriving ecosystem that includes brown and rainbow trout, steelhead, and the rising star of fly fishing: smallmouth bass. What sets Lake Erie apart are the massive smallies that call it home, with specimens reaching five pounds or more, and the occasional behemoth tipping the scales at six or seven pounds.

Pennsylvania’s 46 miles of Lake Erie coastline provide an ideal backdrop for angling adventures. While trout enthusiasts might feel out of their depth pursuing smallmouth, a few tips can turn the tide. Pay attention to the depth at which the fish are holding; these smallies aren’t always surface enthusiasts.

For the best chance at landing hefty smallmouth, spring is your window of opportunity. During this season, these formidable fighters venture from their deepwater sanctuaries to shallower waters. Don’t be fooled by the term “shallow” – they often linger around 15 feet deep.

To conquer this depth challenge, you’ll need to decide between adapting your fly approach or resorting to conventional tackle. The key to success lies in exploring drop-offs, underwater ledges, and sudden depth changes. Smallmouth bass are cunning ambush predators, favoring locations like deep stumps, trees, and boulders, where they can lurk in wait for unsuspecting prey.

Lake Erie’s smallmouth bass offer an unconventional but rewarding fly fishing experience, inviting anglers to embrace the thrill of the unexpected. So, cast aside convention, pick up your fly rod, and embark on an unforgettable adventure along one of the best fly fishing trips in Pennsylvania.

3. Allegheny River

Allegheny River
Image via The Allegheny Front

Nestled within the breathtaking Allegheny National Forest, the Allegheny River is best fly fishing trips in Pennsylvania for fly fishing enthusiasts seeking an adventure in pursuit of trophy-sized trout.

The crown jewel of the Allegheny River is undoubtedly the 9-mile-long Trophy Section, where anglers can cast their lines in pursuit of some truly impressive brown trout.

These aren’t your ordinary trout–they are seasoned holdovers from previous stockings, and they regularly grow to sizes exceeding 18 inches. Every year, lucky fishermen even manage to reel in those coveted “dirty thirty” monsters, making for stories that last a lifetime.

Accessibility is a breeze along the Allegheny, particularly beneath the Kinzua Dam. Highway 59 and Hemlock Road run alongside, offering convenient access points for eager anglers.

However, success on this river is intimately tied to understanding the dam’s water levels. Low water can slow the fishing action, while high water can render wading unsafe. To conquer the Allegheny, one must learn the rhythm of its flow and embrace the thrill of the chase in one of nature’s most stunning settings.

4. Fishing Creek

Fishing Creek
Image via Wikipedia

The Fishing Creek stands as a testament to the allure of fly fishing. Renowned among avid trout anglers, this legendary waterway has earned its reputation as one of the state’s premier trout streams. A sanctuary for both seasoned anglers and newcomers alike, Fishing Creek offers an immersive, natural experience that transcends the mere act of fishing.

One of the creek’s notable features is its accessibility, with a wealth of public and private fishing areas that dot its meandering course. Stocked in strategic locations, this stream promises an abundance of opportunities to test your angling skills and savor the thrill of a catch. Whether you seek the challenge of catching wild trout or prefer the stocked variety, Fishing Creek caters to all preferences.

In these serene waters, every cast becomes a chance to connect with nature, find tranquility, and experience the thrill of reeling in a prized trout. Fishing Creek, with its rich history and natural beauty, continues to beckon those who yearn for the authentic fly fishing adventure that defines Pennsylvania’s angling legacy.

5. Youghiogheny River

Youghiogheny River
Image by greekmiss on Flickr

The Youghiogheny River is a fly-fisher’s paradise waiting to be explored. This pristine waterway, affectionately known as the “Yough” by locals, offers an unforgettable angling experience and among the best fly fishing trips in Pennsylvania. Fly fishing in the Youghiogheny River is a harmonious blend of natural beauty and the art of angling.

The Youghiogheny River is renowned for its exceptional trout fishing. Its crystal-clear waters are home to a thriving population of rainbow, brown, and brook trout. As you wade through the river’s cool currents, surrounded by lush forests and towering cliffs, you’ll find yourself immersed in a serene, almost meditative, experience.

The Youghiogheny’s diverse aquatic insect life sustains a vibrant trout population, making it a prime destination for fly fishing enthusiasts year-round. Whether you’re a seasoned angler or a novice, the Yough offers a wide range of fishing experiences, from challenging deep pools to gentle riffles.

6. Lehigh River

Lehigh River
Image by GregoryPierce-123 on Flickr

The Lehigh River is a fly fishing haven that stretches over 100 miles and stands as the Delaware River’s largest tributary. This section teems with a thriving population of wild browns and rainbows, further bolstered by private organizations like the Lehigh River Stocking Association, which regularly replenishes the river’s stock.

But the Lehigh River isn’t just about trout. It also hosts a robust population of smallmouth bass, making it a versatile destination for fly anglers. What truly sets this river apart, though, is its incredible insect diversity, with an array of mayflies, caddisflies, and stoneflies calling it home.

When it comes to fishing methods, drift boat fishing reigns supreme here. The Lehigh River’s characteristics make it more reminiscent of Western rivers than Eastern ones, providing a unique experience for fly fishermen. This method allows you to explore the river’s depths, even in challenging whitewater conditions that would be perilous for wading. Hooking a sizeable fish in these turbulent waters is a memorable adventure.

With its exceptional trout and bass populations, diverse insect life, and thrilling drift boat fishing, the Lehigh River is an Eastern gem that deserves recognition among the finest fly fishing destinations. Whether you’re casting in the brisk early months of April through June or returning for the Fall bounty, the Lehigh River promises an unforgettable angling experience and a chance to create lasting memories on the water.

7. Clarion River

Clarion River
Image via Adventure Bound on the Fly

The Clarion River emerges as a hidden gem for fly fishing enthusiasts. This pristine waterway, tracing its course alongside Route 219 below Wilcox, offers a captivating angling experience accessible directly from the road or via nearby state parks like Bendigo State Park.

One of the defining features of Clarion River is its accessibility without the need for a boat. However, it’s essential to note that wading is off-limits near Tambine. For those in search of native brook trout, the Delayed Harvest section is a well-kept secret among fly fishermen, often providing solitude and exceptional fishing opportunities.

The beauty of Clarion River lies in its year-round appeal. Spring ushers in abundant insect hatches, including mayflies and caddis, creating a fly angler’s paradise. Autumn offers not only stunning foliage but also the chance to land hefty holdover or wild brown trout during their spawning season.

Even winter doesn’t deter the avid angler, with the East Branch’s relatively warmer waters providing refuge. Summer beckons, too, with cooler waters in the East Branch ensuring fly fishing remains enjoyable. Whether you seek solitude, pristine nature, or a year-round fishing adventure, Clarion River is a haven for fly fishing enthusiasts of all stripes.

8. Susquehanna River

Susquehanna River
Image via Go Erie

Fly fishing in the Susquehanna River is a thrilling angling adventure that promises a diverse array of target species and unforgettable moments on the water. The river boasts a diverse array of species to target, from the coveted Smallmouth Bass to the elusive Musky, Catfish, Sunfish, Carp, Yellow Perch, Walleye, and Trout.

Smallmouth Bass, locally known as “Smallies,” steal the spotlight here. Their abundance and potential for landing trophy-sized catches make them a favorite among anglers. The Susquehanna River allows year-round fishing, but successful outings vary with the seasons.

During the spring, when the water is still cool, Smallmouth Bass become voracious feeders. Anglers can entice them with hair jigs, often reeling in massive fish. As temperatures rise, Smallies move to deeper waters, making dawn and dusk the prime times for angling success.

After their mid-June spawn, Smallmouth Bass grow larger, with some reaching an impressive 18 inches. Summer angling requires local expertise, making the hiring of a guide highly recommended for an optimal experience. The Susquehanna River is an angler’s paradise, promising not only diverse fishing opportunities but also breathtaking natural beauty along its banks.

9. Hickory Run State Park

Hickory Run State Park
Image via PA Wilds

Hickory Run State Park stands out as a must-visit destination for fly fishing enthusiasts. This natural gem boasts a pristine environment teeming with insect life, creating an angler’s paradise. The park’s pièce de résistance is undoubtedly its stunning waterfall, providing a picturesque backdrop to your fishing expedition.

Flowing gracefully through the park for approximately five miles, Hickory Run is a Class-A stream renowned for its abundant brown and brook trout populations. Whether you’re a seasoned fly fisher or a novice looking to cast your first line, this waterway offers an inviting challenge.

Beyond the fishing, Hickory Run State Park is a versatile outdoor playground, offering activities like hunting, hiking, and even ice skating in winter. Accessing the park is a breeze, thanks to clearly marked signs and ample parking facilities.

While spring brings forth bountiful insect hatches and prime fishing conditions, autumn offers the chance to reel in sizable brown trout. Whatever the season, Hickory Run promises a memorable fly fishing experience in a pristine natural setting.

10. French Creek State Park

French Creek State Park
Image via Wikipedia

Fly fishing in French Creek State Park offers an immersive angling experience amidst the serene beauty of Pennsylvania’s natural landscapes. This angler’s paradise is nestled within the lush woodlands and rolling hills of the park, making it a prime destination for both seasoned fly fishermen and beginners alike.

The creek, winding its way through the park, presents a pristine environment for fly fishing enthusiasts. Its crystal-clear waters teem with trout, bass, and various other species, promising exciting catch-and-release opportunities. The carefully maintained fisheries ensure a sustainable and thriving ecosystem, while the park’s strict regulations preserve its natural beauty.

As you cast your line along the babbling creek, you’ll be surrounded by the park’s tranquil ambiance. The sound of rustling leaves and bird songs harmonize with the rhythmic flow of the water, creating a truly immersive experience.

11. Lycoming Creek

Lycoming Creek
Image via Wikipedia

Lycoming Creek is a fly-fishing haven waiting to be explored. This picturesque stream offers anglers a captivating blend of natural beauty and abundant trout, making it a must-visit destination.

For those eager to cast their lines, timing is key. The prime window coincides with the standard Pennsylvania trout season, which receives a boost from pre-season stocking. The upper reaches of Lycoming Creek are stocked again in mid-April and mid-May, thanks to the shady canopy of trees that keeps the water cool until late May.

As for the aquatic ballet, Lycoming Creek delivers a quintessential Pennsylvania freestone stream experience. It starts in mid-March with the graceful dance of Blue-winged olives and early black stoneflies. April heralds the emergence of Blue Quills, Quill Gordons, and Hendrickson. May and June are the grand performance months, featuring March Browns, Light Cahills, Sulphurs, and a mesmerizing array of mayfly hatches.

Even in the fall, Lycoming Creek doesn’t rest. Small BWOs, slate drakes, and October caddis create a captivating autumn spectacle.

While official state access points are scarce, numerous bridge crossings offer easy entry points. Some nearby campgrounds also grant access, ensuring you can explore the creek’s wonders.

For a truly immersive experience, follow Route 14 above Trout Run, where Lycoming Creek runs close, treating anglers to fantastic riffles and large pools. Come to Lycoming Creek, and let the rhythmic flow of its waters and the allure of its trout cast a spell you won’t soon forget.

12. Spring Creek

Spring Creek
Image via PA Wilds

Spring Creek’s pristine waters have earned it the reputation of a Fisherman’s Paradise. This limestone stream is hailed as the ultimate destination for wild trout enthusiasts. Here, the spotlight shines on the magnificent brown trout, some of which grow up to an impressive 20 inches in length.

While Spring Creek welcomes anglers year-round, the prime season for hatches is from mid-April to mid-July. But be prepared for company during the summer months; this renowned spot attracts anglers from near and far, making competition for both fishing spots and parking spaces a part of the adventure. Whether you’re a seasoned pro or a novice angler, Spring Creek promises an unforgettable fly fishing experience in a breathtaking natural setting.

13. Yellow Breeches Creek

Yellow Breaches Creek
Image via Relentless Fly Fishing

Yellow Breeches Creek beckons anglers from around the world to experience its angling paradise. Stretching over 30 miles, this legendary waterway is celebrated for its diverse trout population, making it a haven for both novices and seasoned fly-fishing enthusiasts.

Yellow Breeches boasts a remarkable blend of stocked and wild trout, offering an exhilarating challenge for those who seek it. With an abundance of rainbow, brown, and brook trout, this meandering creek promises an unforgettable day on the water. The true thrill, however, lies in the pursuit of elusive wild trout, testing an angler’s skill and patience.

Access points are conveniently scattered throughout the region, often near local parks and bridges. The catch and release area near Boiling Springs is a favored spot, but the true treasures of Yellow Breeches Creek extend upstream of Route 15, inviting intrepid souls to explore its hidden gems.

14. Kettle Creek

Kettle Creek
Image via Fly Fisherman

Kettle Creek emerges as a haven for fly fishing enthusiasts seeking an authentic angling adventure. This pristine waterway, stretching from the Billings Branch tributary to the Route 433 Bridge and beyond to Kettle Creek Lake, offers a captivating fly fishing experience.

One of Kettle Creek’s standout features is its Catch-and-Release – Flyfishing Only (CRFFO) section near the SR144 Bridge, ensuring a thriving population of trout even during scorching summers. The upper reaches, between Billings Branch and the 433 Bridge, are a prime spot for wild trout, particularly in the mornings, evenings, and even after nightfall.

While the lower part, closer to Kettle Creek Lake, boasts stocked browns and rainbows, the true angling challenge lies in landing a wild brown or brook trout. Patience and the right flies are key to success here.

The ideal time to visit Kettle Creek is from April to August, coinciding with prolific hatches that lure trout into a feeding frenzy. Keep in mind that summer attracts fellow anglers, so plan ahead and be prepared to explore a bit to find your own secret fishing spot. Kettle Creek, with its abundant natural beauty and thriving trout population, promises an unforgettable fly fishing experience for all who venture here.

15. Young Womans Creek

Image by Brian Masney on Flickr

Young Womans Creek beckons fly fishing enthusiasts with its serene beauty and abundant trout. This hidden gem, accessible from Route 120, offers a quintessential angling experience amidst the enchanting Sproul State Forest. As you venture upstream, cooler waters promise better trout sightings, making it a favorite among anglers seeking the elusive catch.

Young Womans Creek is a wader’s paradise, characterized by its meandering stream, dotted with small pools, pockets, and gentle riffles. The ease of navigation allows for an uninterrupted connection with nature and the thrill of the catch.

Timing your visit is crucial. While the creek remains open year-round, winter brings icy challenges. Early spring emerges as a prime season, showcasing impressive hatches that lure both novice and seasoned fly fishers. Autumn paints a vivid picture as larger brown trout become assertive in preparation for spawning. However, in the summer, tread lightly on the lower sections, as warmer waters make them less hospitable to trout.

Embark on an Angler’s Odyssey: The Best Fly Fishing Trips in Pennsylvania

Pennsylvania emerges as an angler’s paradise, offering some of the best fly fishing trips in Pennsylvania. The Keystone State boasts an impressive array of picturesque rivers, streams, and lakes, each teeming with trout, bass, and other prized fish species.

From the legendary waters of the Delaware River to the serene tranquility of Pine Creek, Pennsylvania provides a range of fly fishing opportunities that cater to anglers of all skill levels. Whether you’re a novice or a seasoned fly fisherman, the state’s waters offer unforgettable moments and a deep connection with nature.

These fly fishing trips encapsulate more than just the pursuit of fish; they represent a harmonious blend of sport, adventure, and the sheer joy of being immersed in Pennsylvania’s breathtaking natural surroundings. So, pack your gear, cast your line, and embark on an angler’s odyssey across the top fly fishing trips in Pennsylvania, where unforgettable moments and pristine waters await.

You May Also Like